Browse Charter sections

Section 11 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms

Proceedings in criminal and penal matters

Section 11 protects people charged with an offence, including proceedings that are criminal in nature or carry true penal consequences. Its guarantees address notice, delay, testimony, fair adjudication, bail, jury trials, retrospective criminal liability, double jeopardy and punishment. The passages below explain these distinct protections and their limits.

11: Proceedings in criminal and penal matters

Any person charged with an offence has the right

(a) to be informed without unreasonable delay of the specific offence;

(b) to be tried within a reasonable time;

(c) not to be compelled to be a witness in proceedings against that person in respect of the offence;

(d) to be presumed innocent until proven guilty according to law in a fair and public hearing by an independent and impartial tribunal;

(e) not to be denied reasonable bail without just cause;

(f) except in the case of an offence under military law tried before a military tribunal, to the benefit of trial by jury where the maximum punishment for the offence is imprisonment for five years or a more severe punishment;

(g) not to be found guilty on account of any act or omission unless, at the time of the act or omission, it constituted an offence under Canadian or international law or was criminal according to the general principles of law recognized by the community of nations;

(h) if finally acquitted of the offence, not to be tried for it again and, if finally found guilty and punished for the offence, not to be tried or punished for it again; and

(i) if found guilty of the offence and if the punishment for the offence has been varied between the time of commission and the time of sentencing, to the benefit of the lesser punishment.

Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms

Unofficial text. Always verify quotes against official sources.

The following selected judicial passages discuss Section 11.

When Section 11 applies

As will be explained, an individual is entitled to the procedural protections of s. 11 of the Charter where the proceeding is, by its very nature, criminal, or where a “true penal consequence” flows from the sanction.

Unofficial text. Always verify quotes against official sources.

Trial, deliberation and sentencing delay

At the heart of the new framework is a ceiling beyond which delay is presumptively unreasonable. The presumptive ceiling is set at 18 months for cases going to trial in the provincial court, and at 30 months for cases going to trial in the superior court (or cases going to trial in the provincial court after a preliminary inquiry).

If the total delay from the charge to the actual or anticipated end of trial (minus defence delay) exceeds the ceiling, then the delay is presumptively unreasonable. To rebut this presumption, the Crown must establish the presence of exceptional circumstances. If it cannot, the delay is unreasonable and a stay will follow.

If the total delay from the charge to the actual or anticipated end of trial (minus defence delay or a period of delay attributable to exceptional circumstances) falls below the presumptive ceiling, then the onus is on the defence to show that the delay is unreasonable. To do so, the defence must establish that (1) it took meaningful steps that demonstrate a sustained effort to expedite the proceedings, and (2) the case took markedly longer than it reasonably should have. We expect stays beneath the ceiling to be rare, and limited to clear cases.

Unofficial text. Always verify quotes against official sources.

Those conclusions give rise to a further question, namely: how should the delay attributable to verdict deliberation time be assessed in determining whether an accused’s right to be tried within a reasonable time has been infringed? The answer, in my view, is that an accused’s right to be tried within a reasonable time under s. 11(b) will have been infringed where the verdict deliberation time is found to have taken markedly longer than it reasonably should have in all of the circumstances. The burden on the accused is, as I will explain, a heavy one due to the operation of the presumption of judicial integrity. This presumption presupposes that trial judges are best placed to balance the various considerations that inform verdict deliberation time, and that the verdict deliberation time taken by a judge in a particular case was no longer than reasonably necessary in the circumstances.

Unofficial text. Always verify quotes against official sources.

Assessing whether post‑verdict sentencing delay was markedly longer than it reasonably should have been invites a contextual inquiry. The question is not whether the delay was long in the abstract, and there is no fixed duration that automatically triggers s. 11(b). The same period of delay may carry very different constitutional significance depending on the complexity of the sentencing exercise, the information required to impose sentence, and the issues that must be resolved. The markedly longer standard is designed to capture this reality.

Importantly, the markedly longer standard is objective and normative in nature. That is, the proper inquiry is whether sentencing proceedings have taken markedly longer than they should reasonably take in a criminal justice system functioning as it ought to in a free and democratic society, not how long it happens to take in a particular jurisdiction given existing resource constraints.

Unofficial text. Always verify quotes against official sources.

Compelled testimony and silence

Three conditions must be met for a person charged with an offence to benefit from the protection against self-incrimination under s. 11 (c) of the Charter : (1) the person must be compelled to be a witness (2) in proceedings against that person (3) in respect of the offence.

Unofficial text. Always verify quotes against official sources.

Rather, it will be for the trial judge, in the exercise of his or her discretion, to provide such an instruction where there is a realistic concern that the jury may place evidential value on an accused’s decision not to testify.

In cases where the jury is given an instruction on the accused’s right to remain silent at trial, the trial judge should, in explaining the right, make it clear to the jury that an accused’s silence is not evidence and that it cannot be used as a makeweight for the Crown in deciding whether the Crown has proved its case.

Unofficial text. Always verify quotes against official sources.

Fair and public adjudication

In light of the above, the right to be presumed innocent until proven guilty requires that s. 11(d) have, at a minimum, the following content. First, an individual must be proven guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. Second, it is the State which must bear the burden of proof. As Lamer J. stated in Dubois v. The Queen, [1985] 2 S.C.R. 350, at p. 357:

Section 11(d) imposes upon the Crown the burden of proving the accused's guilt beyond a reasonable doubt as well as that of making out the case against the accused before he or she need respond, either by testifying or calling other evidence.

Third, criminal prosecutions must be carried out in accordance with lawful procedures and fairness. The latter part of s. 11(d), which requires the proof of guilt "according to law in a fair and public hearing by an independent and impartial tribunal", underlines the importance of this procedural requirement.

Unofficial text. Always verify quotes against official sources.

Although there is obviously a close relationship between independence and impartiality, they are nevertheless separate and distinct values or requirements. Impartiality refers to a state of mind or attitude of the tribunal in relation to the issues and the parties in a particular case. The word "impartial" as Howland C.J.O. noted, connotes absence of bias, actual or perceived. The word "independent" in s. 11 (d) reflects or embodies the traditional constitutional value of judicial independence. As such, it connotes not merely a state of mind or attitude in the actual exercise of judicial functions, but a status or relationship to others, particularly to the executive branch of government, that rests on objective conditions or guarantees.

Unofficial text. Always verify quotes against official sources.

This public scrutiny is to the advantage of the accused in two senses. First, it ensures that the judicial system remains in the business of conducting fair trials, not mere show trials or proceedings in which conviction is a foregone conclusion. The supervision of the public ensures that the state does not abuse the public’s right to be presumed innocent, and does not institute unfair procedures. See Dagenais, supra, at p. 883.

Second, it can vindicate an accused person who is acquitted, particularly when the acquittal is surprising and perhaps shocking to the public. In many cases, it is not clear to the public, without the advantage of a full explanation, why an accused person is acquitted despite what a reasonable person might consider compelling evidence. Where a publication ban is in place, the accused has little public answer.

Unofficial text. Always verify quotes against official sources.

Bail

Lamer C.J. held that there is just cause to deny bail only if the denial (1) occurs in a “narrow set of circumstances” and (2) the denial of bail “is necessary to promote the proper functioning of the bail system and is not undertaken for any purpose extraneous to the bail system”: Pearson, at p. 693; see also Morales, at p. 737; Hall, at para. 16.

[…]

In contrast to the first aspect of the s. 11 (e) right, the right to reasonable bail relates to the terms of bail, including the “quantum of any monetary component and other . . . restrictions” that are imposed on the accused for the release period: Hall, at para. 16. The right not to be denied reasonable bail without just cause protects accused persons from conditions and forms of release that are unreasonable. The French version of s. 11 (e) bears this out: a person charged with an offence has the right to a release “assortie d’un cautionnement raisonnable” (“in conjunction with reasonable bail”).

Unofficial text. Always verify quotes against official sources.

Bail conditions are to be tailored to the individual risks posed by the accused. There should not be a list of conditions inserted by rote. The only bail condition that should be routinely added is the condition to attend court (Birtchnell, at para. 6), as well as those conditions that must be considered for certain offences under s. 515(4.1) to (4.3). There is no problem with referring to checklists to canvass available conditions. The problem arises if conditions are simply added, not because they are strictly necessary, but merely out of habit, because the accused agreed to it, or because some behavior modification is viewed as desirable. Bail conditions may be easy to list, but hard to live.

Unofficial text. Always verify quotes against official sources.

Juries and the military exception

In my view, representativeness focuses on the process used to compile the jury roll, not its ultimate composition. Consequently, the state satisfies an accused’s right to a representative jury by providing a fair opportunity for a broad cross-section of society to participate in the jury process. A fair opportunity will be provided when the state makes reasonable efforts to: (1) compile the jury roll using random selection from lists that draw from a broad cross-section of society, and (2) deliver jury notices to those who have been randomly selected. When this process is followed, the jury roll will be representative and the accused’s Charter right to a representative jury will be respected.

Unofficial text. Always verify quotes against official sources.

It follows, therefore, that a serious civil offence tried as a service offence under s. 130(1)(a) — whether or not there is a heightened “military nexus” — qualifies as “an offence under military law” for the purposes of s. 11(f) of the Charter . Accordingly, where such an offence is tried before a military tribunal — as was the case for each of the accused persons in this instance — the military exception in s. 11(f) of the Charter is engaged.

Unofficial text. Always verify quotes against official sources.

Criminality when the act occurred

Finally, I turn to the last issue, non-publication. In my view s. 11 (g) of the Charter is directed towards the need that impugned conduct be criminal at the time of its commission. That proposition is fundamental, but has nothing to do with the question of how the law is to be made known. Indeed, s. 11(g) embraces criminal law recognized by the community of nations, international law, which is not by its very nature subject to requirements of domestic publication.

The appellants made no reference in argument to s. 7 . I do not propose discussing whether that section may have any impact on the question of publication.

Unofficial text. Always verify quotes against official sources.

Double jeopardy

However, as I explained above, s. 11 (h) may be engaged where no duplication of proceedings has occurred. Retrospective modification of the parole system after an offender was sentenced may have the effect of increasing the offender’s punishment, thereby engaging s. 11 (h). A legislative change that is not in itself punitive can acquire a punitive character by being applied retrospectively.

[…]

I will not articulate a formula that would apply to every case, because such a formula is not needed to resolve this appeal and the effect of every retrospective change will be context-specific. That said, the dominant consideration in each case will in my view be the extent to which an offender’s settled expectation of liberty has been thwarted by retrospective legislative action. It is the retrospective frustration of an expectation of liberty that constitutes punishment. At one extreme, a retrospective change to the rules governing parole eligibility that has the effect of automatically lengthening the offender’s period of incarceration constitutes additional punishment contrary to s. 11 (h) of the Charter . A change that so categorically thwarts the expectation of liberty of an offender who has already been sentenced qualifies as one of the clearest of cases of a retrospective change that constitutes double punishment in the context of s. 11 (h).

Unofficial text. Always verify quotes against official sources.

This rationale is also crucial in Canadian law. Our Court has held that the Crown’s ability to appeal an acquittal does not violate s. 11(h) of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms (R. v. Morgentaler, [1988] 1 S.C.R. 30, at pp. 155-56, per McIntyre J., dissenting, but not on this point). Nevertheless, as Kasirer J.A. noted in LSJPA – 151, the Crown’s [translation] “limited right of appeal seeks to prevent an appeal on the facts to protect acquitted persons from the double jeopardy associated with a new trial” (para. 57 (footnote omitted)).

[…]

Even if the Crown is able to point to an error of law, acquittals are not overturned lightly (see R. v. Cowan, 2021 SCC 45, at para. 46). The Crown must also convince the appellate court, to a reasonable degree of certainty, that the verdict of acquittal would not necessarily have been the same had the error not occurred (Graveline, at para. 15; R. v. Sutton, 2000 SCC 50, [2000] 2 S.C.R. 595, at para. 2). While the Crown need not persuade the appellate court that the verdict would necessarily have been different, its burden in this respect is a very heavy one (see Graveline, at paras. 14-15 and 19, quoting R. v. Morin, [1988] 2 S.C.R. 345, at p. 374; see also Sutton, at para. 2).

Unofficial text. Always verify quotes against official sources.

Lesser punishment

Thus, I would restate the test for punishment as follows in order to carve out a clearer and more meaningful role for the consideration of the impact of a sanction: a measure constitutes punishment if (1) it is a consequence of conviction that forms part of the arsenal of sanctions to which an accused may be liable in respect of a particular offence, and either (2) it is imposed in furtherance of the purpose and principles of sentencing, or (3) it has a significant impact on an offender’s liberty or security interests.

[…]

As this Court wrote in Cunningham v. Canada, [1993] 2 S.C.R. 143: “The Charter does not protect against insignificant or ‘trivial’ limitations of rights . . . . The [state action] must be significant enough to warrant constitutional protection” (p. 151). That is why, if a consequence of conviction is not imposed in furtherance of the purpose and principles of sentencing, it must have a significant impact on an offender’s constitutionally protected liberty or security interests before it will qualify as punishment for the purposes of s. 11(i). To satisfy this requirement, a consequence of conviction must significantly constrain a person’s ability to engage in otherwise lawful conduct or impose significant burdens not imposed on other members of the public.

Unofficial text. Always verify quotes against official sources.

I conclude that, properly interpreted, s. 11(i) confers a binary right, not a global one. Section 11(i) entitles an offender to the lesser of (1) the punishment under the laws in force when the offender committed the offence, and (2) the punishment under the laws in force when the offender is sentenced, as these punishments are tethered to two meaningful points in time. The former reflects the jeopardy or legal risk the offender took by offending. That punishment established, in advance of the offender’s conduct, the legal consequences that would flow from that chosen conduct. The latter is the punishment that society considers just at the precise moment the court is called upon to pass a sentence. It provides the contours for a sentence that reflects society’s most up‑to‑date view of the gravity of the offence and the degree of responsibility of the offender. As these two punishments are clearly connected to the offender’s conduct and criminality, there is a strong and principled basis for the offender to have the constitutional right to receive the lesser of the punishments at these two points in time.

Unofficial text. Always verify quotes against official sources.

The best tool for reading complex documents. Use Eno free: no credit card, no subscription.